Shopify subscriptionssubscribe and savesubscribe and save best practices

Subscribe and Save Best Practices: 7 Tests Worth Running on Shopify

Subscribe and save best practices from real Shopify tests: show the saving in money, add a reason beyond the discount, make cancelling easy to find and repeat the offer in the cart.
Paddy McLarnon
Written by
PM Digital | Founder Paddy McLarnon
Shopify CRO & performance agency for CPG and subscription brands
10 min read
Natrava result card: +9% subscription revenue per visitor from one cart test, shown on the winning cart upgrade block

The best subscribe and save offers on Shopify do four things: they show the saving in money next to the one time price, give a reason to subscribe beyond the discount, put skip, pause and cancel in plain sight, and repeat the offer in the cart. Get those right and a discount you already pay for starts to win more subscribers, without making it any bigger.

Most stores treat subscribe and save as a toggle with a percentage badge. Customers read it differently. They are being asked to agree to future charges, so they want to know what they save, what else they get, how often it arrives and how easy it is to stop.

At PM Digital, Paddy McLarnon and the team design and test subscription offers for Shopify brands. Our view is simple: the offer and the way it is explained usually matter more than another layout change. This guide covers the subscribe and save best practices we use, the tests we would run first, and the results behind them from our published case studies. Where a figure covers a whole programme rather than one test, we say so.

What a subscribe and save offer has to explain

Before you test anything, check that your offer answers the four questions every new subscriber has.

01
What do I save?
The subscription price next to the one time price, with the difference in money. A percentage on its own makes the customer do the maths.
02
What else do I get?
Free delivery, gifts, guides or rewards. These give people a reason to start and a reason to stay that a discount alone does not.
03
How often will it arrive?
A delivery frequency that matches how fast the product is used, shown before the customer adds to cart.
04
How do I stop?
Skip, pause or cancel anytime, written beside the price rather than hidden behind a link or in the FAQs.

The rule we work to: if a customer could subscribe without knowing the price, the frequency and how to cancel, the offer is not finished. Unclear terms cost you subscribers now and refunds later.

Seven subscribe and save tests worth running

These are the tests we usually run first on a subscription store, in roughly the order we would run them. Each one comes from work on a live Shopify brand.

1. Show the saving in money, next to the one time price

On Avantera, the original buy box led with a price per serving, a toggle and a list of terms. Customers were being asked to understand the saving without seeing the actual price difference.

The winning version showed the one time price beside the discounted subscription price, with the delivery cadence and "pause or cancel anytime" in one line underneath. That pattern then became the way subscription savings were shown across the whole funnel: the price you would pay, the price you pay and the gap between them.

We then tested different offer structures and how the monthly price was framed. One experiment increased the share of orders on subscription from 90% to 97%, at 97% confidence.

97%Avantera orders on subscription, up from 90%, one offer test
+9%Natrava subscription revenue per visitor, one cart test
+64%Kiko Vitals subscription sales, compared with the four months before
+40%Adegen mobile product page conversion rate, one buy box test

2. Give people a reason to subscribe beyond the discount

On Cadence, a standard subscribe and save discount was not enough. We tested different incentives, including 30% off the first subscription order, 15% off recurring deliveries, an exclusive Cadence cap, gifts across future deliveries, digital fuelling guides and flexible subscription management.

Staging the gifts across the first three deliveries gives a new subscriber something to look forward to on the second and third orders, when many new subscribers decide whether to stay. On the Funnel First podcast, Matty from Cadence said the merchandise was one of the strongest parts of the strategy: "the biggest one honestly is the merch like the cap".

Cadence Subscribe and Save buy box showing 30% off the first order, 15% off every month and a free
Cadence: the subscription buy box with a gift staged on each of the first three deliveries. From our Cadence case study.

Across the programme we tested ten offer structures, and Cadence's subscription take rate sat around 70%, with a peak of 80%. That figure reflects the whole programme, not one test. If you want to check whether a richer offer still makes money, our offer calculator runs the numbers.

3. Put skip, pause and cancel in plain sight

On Kiko Vitals, the saving was there, but the delivery frequency, what subscribing committed you to and how to pause were not. Fewer people subscribed, and some of those who did asked for refunds because they had not realised.

We rewrote the buy box and cart on every product page with the same structure: the one time price, the subscribe and save price with the saving spelled out, the delivery frequency, free delivery where it applies, and "pause, skip or cancel anytime" in plain sight.

Compared with the four months before, subscription sales through Appstle rose 64% and total sales rose 29%, and 26% of total sales are now on subscription. Those figures cover the whole rebuild, including bundles and promotions, rather than the buy box alone, but almost all of the growth came through subscription.

4. Name the option after the benefit, not the mechanism

"Subscribe" describes what the customer has to do. A label like "Buy more, pay less" describes what they get. On Adegen, the original mobile buy box used text buttons for packages and listed the subscription terms as a block of text.

The winning version showed product images on each package, flagged the most popular and biggest saving options, and led the subscription choice with "Buy more, pay less" and the saving. Mobile conversion rate rose 40% and revenue per visitor rose too, with a 97% probability to beat control. The label was one of several changes in that buy box, so treat it as a test of the whole structure rather than a single line of copy.

Adegen mobile product page buy box with package images, a Subscribe and Save option headed Buy
Adegen: the winning mobile buy box, with the subscription led by the benefit and the saving. From our Adegen case study.

5. Repeat the offer in the cart as an upgrade

Plenty of shoppers add a one time purchase and only think about subscribing once they see their cart. On Natrava, we improved how the subscription saving, free shipping and flexibility were explained in the cart drawer.

The upgrade block spells out the saving, free shipping on the first subscription order and "modify, skip or cancel anytime", with a single Upgrade and Save button. In the winning test, subscription revenue per visitor rose 9% and conversion rate rose 7%. Overall subscription share barely moved, so the gain came from converting more visitors, not from pushing existing buyers into a plan.

Natrava mobile cart drawer with a Subscribe and Save upgrade block: over 20% saving, free frother
Natrava: the cart upgrade block from the winning test. From our Natrava case study.

6. Match the frequency to how fast the product is used

A customer who receives product faster than they use it will skip, pause or cancel, however good the price looks. Set the default frequency from real usage, keep the choice to two or three options, and show it before the customer adds to cart.

If a product gets skipped a lot, try a longer default frequency before you try a bigger discount. Our guide to cutting month three churn covers what to do once people have subscribed.

7. Explain first order offers and defaults honestly

A bigger saving on the first order, such as Cadence's 30% off followed by 15% on recurring deliveries, can be a strong offer. It only works if the customer can see what they pay today and what they will pay next. Shopify's own subscription guidance asks themes to explain how the price changes over time.

The same applies to defaults. Whichever option is selected when the page loads, keep the one time option visible and the terms next to the price, and check the rules for the markets you sell into. Our guide to increasing subscription take rate covers how we test default plans.

How to judge a subscribe and save test

Track three numbers together: subscription share of orders, subscribers per visitor and revenue per visitor.

A test can push subscription share up by putting off one time buyers, and that shows up as a fall in revenue per visitor. That is why every test on our CRO & Scale Plan is judged on revenue per visitor and take rate together. Our guide to revenue per visitor explains why it is the guardrail.

We run many of these tests in AB Genius, the Shopify A/B testing app built by our team, so offers, buy boxes and cart blocks can be tested on real traffic without a developer rebuilding the page each time.

A subscribe and save checklist

01
Show both prices
The one time price and the subscription price side by side, with the saving in money.
02
Add a reason to stay
Free delivery, a gift on later deliveries or a useful guide, so the offer is not only a discount.
03
State the terms plainly
Frequency, skip, pause and cancel in one line under the price, and again in the cart.
04
Lead with the benefit
Label the option after what the customer gets, and test that wording against your current label.
05
Offer the upgrade in the cart
One clear block with the saving, the perks and a single upgrade button.
06
Judge on revenue per visitor
Take rate and subscribers per visitor, with revenue per visitor as the guardrail.

The takeaway

Subscribe and save is not a badge. It is a promise, and customers subscribe when the promise is clear. Show the saving in money, give a reason beyond the discount, make the exit easy to find and repeat the offer in the cart. Then test the framing, because that is usually where the next gain is.

For the wider picture, read our complete guide to subscription CRO and what to put on a subscription landing page. You can see the full programmes behind these examples on our Shopify CRO case studies page, how we work with subscription brands on our Shopify CRO for subscription brands page, and how we work more widely on our Shopify CRO agency page. If you are comparing partners, we also keep a list of the best CRO agencies for subscription brands.

Frequently asked questions

What are the best practices for subscribe and save on Shopify?
Show the subscription price next to the one time price with the saving in money, add a benefit beyond the discount, state the delivery frequency and the skip, pause or cancel terms beside the price, and repeat the offer in the cart.
How much discount should a subscribe and save offer give?
There is no single right number. Test the structure as well as the size: a first order discount, free delivery or gifts on later deliveries can beat a bigger flat discount. Check every offer against your margins before you launch it.
Should I show the saving as a percentage or in money?
Show it in money, beside the one time price. On Avantera, showing the one time price next to the subscription price set the pattern for every page in the funnel. A percentage can sit alongside it, but money is easier to understand.
Where should subscribe and save appear apart from the product page?
In the cart, as a clear upgrade. On Natrava, a cart upgrade block lifted subscription revenue per visitor by 9% in the winning test. A sticky add to cart on mobile can also keep the offer in view as people scroll.
How do I measure whether a subscribe and save change worked?
Look at subscription share of orders and subscribers per visitor, with revenue per visitor as the guardrail, so a higher take rate is not costing you one time buyers.
Next step
Want your subscribe and save offer to win more subscribers?
Have a chat with Paddy, our founder, about where your subscription offer is today. We test subscription offers, buy boxes and carts for Shopify brands on Recharge, Appstle and other subscription apps.
Talk with Paddy
A chat with our founder about where the brand is.
We'll look at what you need, audit if it's needed, then talk about how we could work together. No deck, no obligation.
Book a discovery call WhatsApp us
Paddy McLarnon
Written by
Paddy McLarnon
Founder of PM Digital. Runs full-funnel CRO programmes for CPG and subscription brands on Shopify, and writes about offers, positioning and what the tests actually show.

How we work

Built for what happens after the click.

Most brands don't need more traffic. They need the traffic they already pay for to convert.

We work on what happens after the click, on the CRO and Scale Plan. Decisions are driven by the data in the CRO Brain, with PMD Cortex AI supporting the team, and a programme of tests rather than one lucky win.

The founder and the team

Paddy McLarnon, founder, and the team that does the work.

Paddy McLarnon founded PM Digital and has been a name in CRO for the last four years. He takes the first call with every brand himself, and stays close to the strategy. He has spoken at DTC Growth Summit in Miami and New York, and hosts the Funnel First podcast.

Meet the agency
Paddy McLarnon, founder of PM Digital, speaking at DTC Growth Summit Miami
Founder, speaking at DTC Growth Summit Miami

Our team

The in-house team behind the work.

Your pod does the work, and the whole team backs it. Plus you, in a dedicated Slack channel with all of them.