increase subscription take rateshopify subscribe and saveShopify subscriptions

How to Increase Subscription Take Rate on Shopify

A practical guide to the buy box, default plan and offer tests that move more Shopify customers onto a recurring order.
Paddy McLarnon
Written by
PM Digital | Founder Paddy McLarnon
Shopify CRO & performance agency for CPG and subscription brands
12 min read

Subscription take rate is the share of eligible Shopify purchases that choose a recurring plan rather than a one-time order. It usually rises when the buy box, the default selection and the offer make subscribe the clearer, lower-risk choice, while one-time purchase stays visible. Measure take rate alongside revenue per visitor and retention, not first-order conversion alone.

Most subscription brands treat take rate as a design problem. They move a toggle, change a label, or hide the one-time option, then wonder why first-order conversion fell or why new subscribers asked for refunds. The brands that improve take rate in a commercially useful way usually change three things together: what the customer is choosing, how clearly that choice is explained, and which option is presented as the natural default.

This guide covers those levers, and how to judge a test so a higher take rate does not quietly damage profit. The proof below comes only from published PM Digital case studies. Where a figure reflects a wider partnership rather than a single isolated test, that is stated. If you are comparing agencies that specialise in this work, start with our review of the best CRO agencies for subscription brands.

What subscription take rate actually measures

Define the metric before you test anything. First-order take rate is typically the share of new customers whose first order includes a subscription. Order-level take rate is the share of qualifying orders placed on a recurring plan. The two can move in different directions if returning customers already subscribe at a high rate.

Pick one primary definition, keep the denominator consistent, and do not mix them in the same report. Then decide which supporting numbers can overturn a result that looks good on take rate alone: conversion rate, revenue per visitor, average order value, and later retention or cancellation.

A result that adds subscribers while cutting first-order revenue per visitor may still be worth shipping if those subscribers stay. It may also be a loss if the extra discount, gift or free shipping makes the first box unprofitable and many people cancel before a second delivery. Take rate is the decision metric. It is not the only commercial metric.

Natrava case study results: +9.07% subscription revenue per visitor and +7.42% conversion rate from
Natrava: the winning cart test lifted subscription revenue per visitor 9.07% (observed, about 85% probability). From our Natrava case study.

The four tests that usually move take rate

Use this comparison when you are deciding what to change first on a Shopify product page or cart.

Lever What you change What to watch
Offer structure First-order discount, recurring saving, gifts, staged rewards, or a stronger reason to stay subscribed Take rate, revenue per visitor, margin and later retention
Buy box clarity Price, saving, delivery frequency, and pause, skip or cancel language in plain sight Take rate, refunds from people who did not realise they had subscribed, and conversion rate
Default plan Which option is pre-selected, and whether subscribe appears first Take rate against conversion rate and revenue per visitor, split by mobile and desktop
Cart upgrade A clear subscribe offer at the point someone is reviewing the basket Subscription revenue per visitor and subscription orders per visitor, not mix shift alone

A useful rule: if a customer cannot see what they will pay, how often the order arrives, and how they can pause or cancel, you are not testing a better subscription. You are testing a more confusing one.

1. Test the offer before you spend a year on layout

A standard Subscribe & Save percentage is often not enough, especially once a brand has a range to explain and a habit to sell. On the Cadence case study, the work started with customer research and offer testing rather than another rearrangement of the page. Across the 12 months, 10 offer structures were explored, including first-order discounts, quantity discounts, gift-with-subscription, starter bundles and hydration systems.

Each offer was judged against conversion rate, revenue per visitor and subscription take rate. An offer that increased average order value was not automatically a winner if it moved customers away from subscribing. The published case study is clear about the commercial test: the value of a recurring customer could be considerably greater than a single larger order.

For Cadence, that included incentives beyond a plain discount: 30% off the first subscription order, 15% off recurring deliveries, an exclusive cap, additional gifts across future deliveries, digital nutrition guides, and flexible subscription management. On the Funnel First podcast, Matty Martin, Head of Marketing at Cadence, described the exclusive merchandise as one of the strongest parts of the strategy, because customers identified with the brand and subscription gave them a reason to start and reasons to stay.

70%Subscription take rate during the Cadence partnership
80%Peak take rate reported in testing
10Offer structures tested across the 12 months
Nearly 2%Site conversion rate, from under 1%, over 12 months on our CRO & Scale Plan

Those Cadence figures come from 12 months on our CRO & Scale Plan, not from one buy box tweak. The published case study also reports 389% revenue growth during the partnership and is explicit that this reflects Cadence's wider business performance, including its own acquisition, brand and retail work. It should not be read as incremental revenue attributable solely to PM Digital. What the work does show is the principle: give customers a reason to subscribe, then a reason to stay.

Kiko Vitals value stacked Subscribe and Save buy box with free delivery, skip or pause and cancel
Kiko Vitals' rebuilt Subscribe and Save buy box spells out what a subscriber gets. From our Kiko Vitals case study.

2. Make the buy box impossible to misread

If the saving is visible but the commitment is not, two problems appear at once. Fewer people subscribe, and some of those who do later ask for a refund because they had not understood the plan. That is what we found on the original Kiko Vitals product pages: delivery frequency, the saving and the ability to pause or cancel were not explained clearly in the buy box or cart.

The rebuilt buy box and cart used the same structure on every product page: the one-off price, the Subscribe & Save price with the saving spelled out, the delivery frequency, free delivery where it applied, and "pause, skip or cancel anytime" in plain sight. Clarity itself became an offer lever. Explaining the subscription properly increased the number of people willing to take it, and reduced the number who regretted it.

During the Kiko Vitals partnership, Appstle subscription sales rose 64% compared with the previous four months. In the same period, total sales rose 29%, orders rose 42% and average order value rose 11%. Online store one-off orders grew 3%, so almost all of the sales growth came through subscription. These are store-wide results from our CRO & Scale Plan, so they include Kiko's own marketing too. Shopify also changed how it counts sessions in that period, which is why the published case study reports orders, add to carts and checkouts rather than a headline conversion-rate lift.

3. Give each type of buyer a clear row

A single subscribe toggle asks three different customers to make the same motion: someone ready to commit, someone who wants a larger first supply, and someone who only wants to try the product once. On Natrava, the buy box moved from that single toggle to three clear ways to buy: Subscribe & Save with the saving in dollars and the terms spelled out, a 3-month pack for first-time users who want results at a lower monthly cost, and a one-time option that still nudges towards subscription.

That structure does not force every visitor down one path. It makes the recurring option the most complete explanation of value, while leaving a genuine alternative for people who are not ready. If you remove the one-time option entirely, you may inflate take rate and damage conversion at the same time. Natrava's published work includes a subscription-only experiment where overall conversion declined, even as subscription revenue and subscription order mix increased. The team treated that as a learning about presentation, not as proof that removing choice is the answer.

4. Test the default plan without hiding the alternative

Pre-selecting Subscribe & Save, and placing it first, is one of the most common take-rate tests on Shopify. It can work because many customers accept the highlighted option when the offer already looks better. It can also backfire if the default feels like a trick, if the terms are easy to miss, or if the cheapest subscribe option is a single item that loses money once you add the extra discount and free shipping.

We have not published a standalone, isolated A/B result that isolates "default on" versus "default off" on a client case study page. The honest way to run the test is still straightforward. Keep one-time purchase visible. Spell out the saving, frequency and cancellation terms next to the selected plan. Set a floor on what can be subscribed to if a tiny first box would lose money. Then read the result on take rate, conversion rate and revenue per visitor, and split mobile from desktop before you ship it everywhere.

If take rate rises and revenue per visitor holds or improves, you have a commercial win. If take rate rises only because conversion fell, look at whether the default created anxiety rather than clarity. Kiko Vitals' refunds from people who "didn't know they subscribed" are a reminder that an uninformed default is not a good default.

Natrava cart drawer subscription upgrade block spelling out the saving, free shipping on the first
Natrava's winning cart variation: the saving, free shipping and flexibility spelled out at the point of purchase. From our Natrava case study.

5. Repeat the offer in the cart, not only on the product page

Some visitors decide to subscribe on the product page. Others only weigh it up when they see the basket total. Natrava's winning cart experiment rebuilt the subscription upgrade block so it spelled out the saving, free shipping on the first subscription order, and the ability to modify, skip or cancel anytime, with a single Upgrade and Save action.

+9.07%Subscription revenue per visitor
+7.37%Subscription orders per visitor
+7.49%Overall revenue per visitor
+7.42%Conversion rate

Overall subscription share barely moved. The gain came from converting more visitors into customers, which is why subscription revenue per visitor rose even though the mix of orders stayed similar. For returning visitors, revenue per visitor rose 29% and subscription share moved from 68.2% to 75.1%. The test ran for two weeks. The published case study reports about an 85% probability that the variation was best, so these are observed experiment results rather than a statistically conclusive causal uplift.

That distinction matters. A cart upgrade can grow subscription revenue without forcing a higher mix. Sometimes the best way to increase subscription take rate among people who were going to buy anyway is to make the final decision easier to understand.

How to judge whether the test is actually a win

Before you launch, write down the decision rule. A take-rate winner should also be acceptable on revenue per visitor, or you should have a clear reason to trade short-term basket value for better recurring economics. Check the first subscription order too. If the new default steers people to a small, heavily discounted box with free shipping, take rate can look healthy while contribution falls.

Then look beyond the first order. Retention work is a different job from first-order take rate, and a higher subscribe rate does not automatically mean better long-term value. For the later part of the journey, our guide to Shopify subscription optimisation and churn reduction covers the month-three problem separately. The same principle applies at both ends of the funnel: customers need a reason to start, and a reason to stay.

More examples of this work sit on our Shopify CRO case studies page, including Cadence, Natrava and Kiko Vitals.

8 Sheep quantity buy box: one, two or three bottles with subscribe and save on the single bottle
8 Sheep's buy box: 15% off two, 20% off three, and subscribe and save on the single bottle only. From our 8 Sheep case study.

The takeaway

You increase subscription take rate on Shopify by making the recurring option the obvious, well-explained choice, not the hidden one and not the only one. Start with an offer that is worth choosing. Make the buy box state the price, the saving, the frequency and the way out. Test which plan is selected by default without removing one-time purchase. Repeat the same offer in the cart.

Then judge the winner the way a subscription business should: take rate, revenue per visitor, and whether those new subscribers understood what they bought well enough to stay.

If you want a team to run those tests with you, our Shopify CRO agency works on subscription take rate as part of a full-funnel programme, and our homepage sets out how that work is scoped.

Frequently asked questions

What is subscription take rate on Shopify?
It is the share of eligible purchases or customers that choose a recurring plan instead of a one-time order. Define the denominator before you test, and keep using the same definition when you compare results.
How do you increase subscription take rate?
Test the offer, the buy box explanation, the default selection and the cart upgrade. On published PM Digital work, Cadence reached a 70% take rate during a partnership that tested 10 offer structures, Kiko Vitals saw subscription sales rise 64% after the subscribe terms were made clear, and a Natrava cart test lifted subscription revenue per visitor by 9.07%.
Should Subscribe & Save be selected by default?
It is a test worth running, not an automatic rule. Keep the one-time option visible, explain pause, skip or cancel next to the selected plan, and ship the variant only if take rate improves without an unacceptable drop in conversion or revenue per visitor.
Can a clearer buy box raise take rate without a bigger discount?
Yes. If customers cannot see delivery frequency, the saving or how to pause, they often avoid the plan or subscribe by mistake. Kiko Vitals' published work shows that spelling those details out can support subscription growth without relying on a new discount alone.
What else should I measure besides take rate?
Track conversion rate, revenue per visitor, average order value and later retention or cancellations. A higher take rate can still be a poor result if first-order profit falls or if new subscribers cancel before a second delivery.
Talk with Paddy
A chat with our founder about where the brand is.
We'll look at what you need, audit if it's needed, then talk about how we could work together. No deck, no obligation.
Book a discovery call WhatsApp us
Paddy McLarnon
Written by
Paddy McLarnon
Founder of PM Digital. Runs full-funnel CRO programmes for CPG and subscription brands on Shopify, and writes about offers, positioning and what the tests actually show.

How we work

Built for what happens after the click.

Most brands don't need more traffic. They need the traffic they already pay for to convert.

We work on what happens after the click, on the CRO and Scale Plan. Decisions are driven by the data in the CRO Brain, with PMD Cortex AI supporting the team, and a programme of tests rather than one lucky win.

The founder and the team

Paddy McLarnon, founder, and the team that does the work.

Paddy McLarnon founded PM Digital and has been a name in CRO for the last four years. He takes the first call with every brand himself, and stays close to the strategy. He has spoken at DTC Growth Summit in Miami and New York, and hosts the Funnel First podcast.

Meet the agency
Paddy McLarnon, founder of PM Digital, speaking at DTC Growth Summit Miami
Founder, speaking at DTC Growth Summit Miami

Our team

The in-house team behind the work.

Your pod does the work, and the whole team backs it. Plus you, in a dedicated Slack channel with all of them.