above the foldlanding pagesShopify subscriptions

Subscription Landing Page: What to Put Above the Fold and in the Buy Box

What a subscription landing page needs on the first screen and in the buy box, with real examples from 8 Sheep Organics, Kiko Vitals, Natrava, Avantera and Cadence.
Paddy McLarnon
Written by
PM Digital | Founder Paddy McLarnon
Shopify CRO & performance agency for CPG and subscription brands
10 min read
Avantera result card: 97% of orders on subscription, up from 90%, from one offer test

Above the fold, a subscription landing page needs five things: a headline that repeats the promise from the ad, one line of proof, a reason the product works better with regular use, a single clear button and the subscription terms in plain English. Further down, the buy box has to show the subscription saving in money, give each kind of buyer their own option and repeat the terms so nobody subscribes by accident.

A one time landing page only has to win the first order. A subscription page has to win the second, third and fourth orders too, on the first visit, often from someone who has never heard of the brand.

This guide covers what we put on the first screen and in the buy box when we build subscription pages for Shopify brands. Every example and figure comes from a published PM Digital case study, and we say when a figure is store wide rather than the result of one test.

Why subscription pages need a different first screen

Most subscription friction is not about price. It is about trust and control.

On Kiko Vitals, the delivery frequency, the saving and the option to pause or cancel were not explained in the buy box or the cart. Some customers asked for refunds because they had not realised they had subscribed.

On Avantera Health, customers were being asked to understand the subscription saving without always seeing the actual price difference.

So the page has to earn trust before it asks for a recurring commitment. That starts on the first screen, not at the buy box.

The rule we work to: the first screen sells the outcome and the reason to keep taking the product. The buy box sells the subscription. If the first screen does its job, the buy box has an easier conversation.

What to put above the fold

These are the five elements we check on every subscription landing page before anything else.

01
A headline that matches the ad
Repeat the promise or problem the ad used, in the customer's words. A visitor who clicked on a stretch mark ad should land on a stretch mark headline, not a brand slogan.
02
One line of proof
A star rating and review count, or a short line about who uses the product, placed near the headline. Keep it to one line so it supports the headline rather than competing with it.
03
A reason to keep taking it
The subhead should hint at why the product works with regular use. That is what makes subscribing feel like the sensible way to buy later on the page.
04
One clear button
One primary action. If some visitors are not ready, a quieter secondary route such as a quiz link can sit underneath, but it should never look like a second main button.
05
The terms in plain English
When the offer appears on the first screen, put the saving and "skip, pause or cancel anytime" right next to it. Hidden terms cost you subscribers now and refunds later.
06
Nothing else fighting for attention
Pop-ups, countdown bars and long announcement banners push the headline and button down, especially on mobile. Keep anything above the headline to one compact line.

Here is what that looks like on the 8 Sheep Organics education page we designed and built for cold Meta traffic. The rating line, the headline, a one sentence subhead and a single button are all visible before the visitor scrolls.

8 Sheep Organics education landing page above the fold on desktop: star rating line, headline about
8 Sheep Organics: rating, headline, subhead and one button on the first screen. The page has been live for more than 14 months. From our 8 Sheep case study.

The 8 Sheep page explains the problem first, then the science, then the offer. Subscribe and Save sits further down in the buy box, on the single bottle only, because 8 Sheep's subscribers almost always choose one unit.

The Kiko Vitals PMS landing page takes the same approach for a different visitor. The headline repeats the standard advice its visitors have already been given, the rating sits above it, and visitors who are not sure where to start get a quiz link under the main button.

Kiko Vitals PMS landing page above the fold: 4.94 out of 5 rating, a headline in the customer's
Kiko Vitals: a headline in the customer's own words, one main button and a quiet quiz route for visitors who are not ready. From our Kiko Vitals case study.

If you are building pages for paid social, our cold traffic landing page framework covers how to match the first screen to the ad angle in more detail.

Carry the offer down the page on mobile

On a long landing page, most mobile visitors scroll well past the first screen before they decide. If the offer only lives in the hero and the buy box, it disappears for most of the scroll.

On Natrava, the default sticky bar only said Shop now. The subscription led version carries the $10 saving, the free gift, the monthly price and "skip or cancel anytime" all the way down the page.

Natrava mobile sticky add to cart: the default bar with a Shop now button beside a subscription led
Natrava: the default sticky bar on the left and the subscription led version on the right. From our Natrava case study.

Natrava's annual Shopify sales grew 71% year on year. That figure is store wide and includes Natrava's own marketing. In a separate winning cart test, subscription revenue per visitor rose 9% and conversion rate rose 7%, by making the saving, free shipping and flexibility clear where customers review their order.

What to put in the buy box

The first screen earns the scroll. The buy box closes the subscription. These are the patterns that have held up across our subscription clients.

Show the saving in money

Avantera's original buy box led with a price per serving, a toggle and a list of terms, so customers had to work out the saving themselves. The winning variation showed the one time price next to the discounted subscription price, with the delivery cadence and "pause or cancel anytime" in one line underneath.

That became the pattern for the rest of the funnel: the price you would pay, the price you pay and the gap between them.

Frame the deal, not only the discount

Once subscription is already the most common choice, a bigger discount is not usually what moves people. Avantera tested different offer structures, including the size of the first order discount, how the monthly price was framed and what sat next to the button.

97%Avantera orders on subscription, up from 90%, at 97% confidence
5%Avantera subscribers per visitor, up from 4%, lower confidence
+389%Cadence revenue growth over 12 months
Nearly 2%Cadence conversion rate, up from under 1%

On Cadence, a standard Subscribe and Save discount was not enough, so we tested ten offer structures, including free gifts staged across the first deliveries. Over 12 months on our CRO & Scale Plan, Cadence's revenue grew 389%, conversion went from under 1% to nearly 2%, and subscription take rate sat around 70%. The revenue figure reflects Cadence's wider business, including its own marketing and retail growth, not one test.

Give each kind of buyer their own row

Natrava's buy box used to have a single subscribe toggle. A subscriber, a bulk buyer and someone who wants to try the product once are three different customers, and one toggle forced all three through the same choice.

The rebuilt buy box gave each of them a row: Subscribe and Save with the saving in dollars and the terms spelled out, a three month pack for first timers who want results at a lower monthly cost, and a one time option that still nudges towards subscription.

Make the terms impossible to miss

The original Kiko Vitals buy box had a price, two radio buttons and a Save 15% badge. There was no delivery frequency, no saving in rand and nothing about pausing or cancelling.

Kiko Vitals buy box before and after: the original with one time purchase selected and a small Save
Kiko Vitals: the original buy box above, the value stacked Subscribe and Save buy box below. From our Kiko Vitals case study.

We rebuilt the buy box and cart on every product page with the same structure: the one off price, the Subscribe and Save price with the saving spelled out, the delivery frequency, free delivery where it applies, and pause, skip or cancel in plain sight.

Compared with the four months before, Kiko's total sales rose 29% and subscription sales rose 64%. Those are store wide Shopify figures from the full rebuild, so they include Kiko's own marketing too.

What these examples have in common

None of the gains came from shouting a bigger discount. They came from a first screen that matched the visitor, and a buy box where the saving and the terms were impossible to misread.

A checklist for your subscription landing page

01
Open with the ad's promise
The first screen repeats what the ad said, then hints at why the product works with regular use.
02
Prove it before you sell it
A rating line near the headline, then reviews, results and studies beside the claims before the buy box.
03
Show both prices
The one time price and the subscription price side by side, with the saving in money.
04
State the terms in plain English
Delivery frequency, skip, pause and cancel, in one line under the price and again in the cart.
05
Give each buyer a row
Subscription, a multi pack and one time, so nobody is forced through a choice that does not suit them.
06
Carry it down the page and into the cart
A sticky add to cart on mobile keeps the offer in view, and the cart confirms the saving and terms.

How to measure it

Track three numbers together: subscription share of orders, subscribers per visitor and revenue per visitor.

A page can push subscription share up by putting off one time buyers, and that shows up as a fall in revenue per visitor. Our guide to revenue per visitor explains why that matters, and our LTV to CAC toolkit shows how to judge the subscribers you win over time.

For the wider picture, read our complete guide to subscription CRO, our guide to increasing subscription take rate, how to cut month three churn once people have subscribed, and our subscribe and save best practices for the offer itself.

The takeaway

A good subscription landing page sells the habit, not just the product. The first screen matches the ad, proves it in one line and gives one clear next step. The buy box shows the saving in money, gives each buyer a row and states the terms plainly.

Then test the framing, because once subscription is the default, framing is usually where the next gain is. You can see the full programmes behind these examples on our Shopify CRO case studies page, how we build pages on our Shopify landing pages page, and how we work on our Shopify CRO agency page. If you are comparing partners, we also keep a list of the best CRO agencies for subscription brands.

Frequently asked questions

What should go above the fold on a subscription landing page?
A headline that matches the ad, one line of proof such as a rating, a subhead that hints at why the product works with regular use, one clear button and, if the offer is shown, the saving and the skip or cancel terms beside it.
Should the subscription offer be on the first screen?
Not always. For cold traffic, the first screen usually needs to sell the outcome first. When the offer does appear, show the saving in money and the terms next to it, and carry the offer down the page with a sticky add to cart on mobile.
Should subscription be the default option in the buy box?
Often, yes, but defaulting is not enough on its own. On Avantera, subscription was already the default, and the remaining gain came from how the deal was framed. Test the framing as well as the default.
How do I stop customers saying they did not know they subscribed?
Put the delivery frequency, the saving and the skip or cancel terms in the buy box and again in the cart. Unclear terms led to refunds on Kiko Vitals from customers who did not know they had subscribed.
Which metrics should I use to judge a subscription landing page?
Subscription share of orders and subscribers per visitor, with revenue per visitor as the guardrail so a higher take rate is not costing you customers overall.
Next step
Want more first orders to become subscriptions?
Have a chat with Paddy, our founder, about where your subscription funnel is today. We build and test subscription landing pages, buy boxes and carts for Shopify brands on Recharge, Appstle and other subscription apps.
Talk with Paddy
A chat with our founder about where the brand is.
We'll look at what you need, audit if it's needed, then talk about how we could work together. No deck, no obligation.
Book a discovery call WhatsApp us
Paddy McLarnon
Written by
Paddy McLarnon
Founder of PM Digital. Runs full-funnel CRO programmes for CPG and subscription brands on Shopify, and writes about offers, positioning and what the tests actually show.

How we work

Built for what happens after the click.

Most brands don't need more traffic. They need the traffic they already pay for to convert.

We work on what happens after the click, on the CRO and Scale Plan. Decisions are driven by the data in the CRO Brain, with PMD Cortex AI supporting the team, and a programme of tests rather than one lucky win.

The founder and the team

Paddy McLarnon, founder, and the team that does the work.

Paddy McLarnon founded PM Digital and has been a name in CRO for the last four years. He takes the first call with every brand himself, and stays close to the strategy. He has spoken at DTC Growth Summit in Miami and New York, and hosts the Funnel First podcast.

Meet the agency
Paddy McLarnon, founder of PM Digital, speaking at DTC Growth Summit Miami
Founder, speaking at DTC Growth Summit Miami

Our team

The in-house team behind the work.

Your pod does the work, and the whole team backs it. Plus you, in a dedicated Slack channel with all of them.