Loop Subscriptions review: a Shopify CRO agency's view

Loop Subscriptions is one of the subscription apps in our partner stack. This review is written from a Shopify CRO agency's point of view: what Loop does, how much it costs, the features that matter for subscription brands, and how we set it up so more visitors subscribe and stay.
The app
What is Loop Subscriptions?
Loop Subscriptions is a subscription app for Shopify brands, built by Loop Solutions Inc. On its Shopify App Store listing it holds a 4.9 rating from 820 reviews, and it works with Shopify checkout and customer accounts rather than a separate checkout.
Loop's About page says the company has been bootstrapped from day one and focuses only on subscriptions. Its homepage says more than 1,100 brands have migrated to Loop. Those are Loop's own figures, not ours.
From the official site and listing, the app covers four jobs:
- Acquire: subscription widgets for the product page, selling plans, build your own and preset bundles, checkout links and, on Shopify Plus, checkout upgrades that turn one time buyers into subscribers.
- Retain: cancellation flows, product swaps, win back campaigns and loyalty built into the portal.
- Recover: automatic retries and alerts when a subscription payment fails.
- Grow: portal upsells, personalised upsells, product upgrades and, on Pro, Loop Cart and post purchase offers.
It connects to the tools most DTC brands already use. The listing names Klaviyo, Postscript, Attentive, Gorgias, Rebuy and Shopify Flow among 35+ integrations.
Why we use it
Why PM Digital works with Loop Subscriptions
Loop sits in the subscriptions row of the partner stack on our homepage, next to Recharge, Skio and Stay Ai. PM Digital Design is also listed as a conversion rate optimisation agency in Loop's partner directory.
Here is how the partnership works in practice. We do not resell Loop, and we never push a brand to switch platform for the sake of it. When a brand runs Loop, or decides it suits them, Loop's own team handles the platform side: Loop says migration is included on every paid plan with no setup or migration fees. Our team handles the part that decides whether visitors subscribe: the product page, the subscription widget, the offer, the cart and the tests.
That split matters. A subscription app gives you the plumbing. It does not decide how your offer looks, what it promises or where it sits in the buy box. That is where most of the revenue is won or lost, and it is the work we do every day as a Shopify CRO agency.
Paddy McLarnon, our founder, started PM Digital to scale brands properly, not to run small tests on button colours. Every client gets a dedicated pod of strategy, design, development and QA placed into their brand. We also look at how onsite changes affect Meta and paid CAC and CPMs, because a stronger subscription offer changes how much you can afford to pay for a customer.
The CRO view
Is Loop Subscriptions good for CRO?
Yes. From a CRO point of view, three parts of a subscription business move revenue, and Loop has tools for each one.
1. Take rate on the product page
Take rate is the share of buyers who choose subscription over a one time purchase. It is decided in the buy box. Loop's widgets can be styled to match the brand, and its subscription app page describes dynamic discounts that reward longer commitments and build your own bundles that raise recurring order value.
In our experience, the discount alone rarely does the job. The brands that win make the value of subscribing obvious. For Cadence, a standard subscribe and save discount was not enough, so we tested incentives such as 30% off the first order, 15% off recurring deliveries and gifts across future deliveries. The subscription buy box below is the design that came out of that work.

Over 12 months on our CRO & Scale Plan, Cadence moved from converting below 1% to nearly 2%, with a 70% subscription take rate (Cadence case study).
2. Retention after the first order
Subscribers who cancel in the first few months wipe out the value of a strong take rate. Loop's retention overview describes cancellation flows that ask why someone is leaving and give a targeted save for each reason, such as a skip, a delay or a discount, plus routing to live support through Gorgias or Siena. We cover the wider playbook in our guide to cutting subscription churn.
3. Revenue per subscriber
Portal upsells, product upgrades and post purchase offers raise what each subscriber is worth. Higher lifetime value means more room in your paid budget, which is why we judge subscription changes on revenue per visitor and subscription revenue, not on conversion rate alone.
Two more results from subscription brands on our CRO & Scale Plan show what this looks like. Neither ran on Loop, so treat them as proof of the approach, not of the app:
- Kiko Vitals, on Appstle: subscription sales up 64% and total sales up 29% after we rebuilt the product page and subscription offer. These are store-wide figures, so they include the brand's own marketing (Kiko Vitals case study).
- Natrava, on Recharge: one cart test lifted subscription revenue per visitor by 9% and conversion rate by 7% (Natrava case study).

Pricing
Loop Subscriptions pricing
All figures below come from the Loop pricing page and the Shopify App Store listing. Prices are in US dollars.
| Plan | Price and fees | What you get |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0, up to 50 active subscriptions | Mobile portal, subscription alerts, growth and revenue analytics |
| Starter | $99 a month, 1% transaction fee, 15 cents per loyalty order | Bundles, cancellation flows, payment recovery, subscription widgets, loyalty and referrals |
| Pro | $399 a month, 0.75% transaction fee, 10 cents per loyalty order | Dedicated CSM and Slack, Loop Cart, post purchase offers, flows, streaks, cancellation flow A/B testing |
| Enterprise | Custom, negotiable transaction fee | Volume pricing, custom development, custom contract terms, tailored onboarding |
Paid plans come with a 14-day free trial and bill month to month. Loop says there are no per order flat fees and no setup, migration or onboarding fees. Checkout upgrades need Shopify Plus.
For most brands we work with, the choice is between Starter and Pro. Pro adds the tools we use most for retention work, such as flows, streaks and testing cancellation offers against each other, plus a dedicated success manager.
Features
The best Loop Subscriptions features for DTC brands
These are the features we rate most from a CRO point of view, and why.



Setup
How to set up Loop Subscriptions for conversions
Installing Loop takes minutes. Setting it up to convert takes more thought. This is the order we work in with clients.
- Start with customer research. Ask buyers why they chose subscription, or why they did not. We use KnoCommerce for this, and our KnoCommerce review explains how.
- Design the widget into the buy box. Subscription should be the default, with its benefits spelled out inside the option. Our guide to subscribe and save best practices has seven tests worth running.
- Lead with value, not only discount. Gifts across deliveries, free delivery and easy skipping often beat a deeper discount. See how to increase subscription take rate.
- Map every cancellation reason to a save. Too much product gets a skip or delay. Too expensive gets a smaller size or a one off discount.
- Switch on payment recovery early. Failed payments are churn that nobody chose.
- Test it properly. We test buy box and page changes with AB Genius, the Shopify A/B testing app our team built, or Intelligems, and read every result on revenue per visitor and subscription revenue. More on our Shopify A/B testing page.
Who it suits
Is Loop Subscriptions right for your brand?
Loop is built for brands where repeat orders are the business: supplements, food and drink, skincare and other products people run out of. That is also where most of our subscription CRO work sits.
Apparel brands can use it too for replenishable basics, memberships or curated boxes, since the listing supports replenishment, curated and access subscriptions. For most clothing brands, though, the bigger wins are fit, sizing and the collection page, which we cover on our apparel CRO page.
If you are comparing platforms, start with what you need from retention and how much migration help you want, then check pricing at your order volume. Our Skio vs Recharge comparison covers two other apps in our partner row, and our complete guide to subscription CRO covers what to fix whichever app you choose.
Questions
Loop Subscriptions FAQs
What is Loop Subscriptions?
How much does Loop Subscriptions cost?
Does Loop Subscriptions charge setup or migration fees?
Is Loop Subscriptions good for CRO?
Does PM Digital work with Loop Subscriptions?
Sources for Loop facts: the Loop Subscriptions website, its pricing page, About page, subscription app page and Help Center retention overview, and the Loop Subscriptions Shopify App Store listing. App images are from that listing. See all our case studies.

How we work
Built for what happens after the click.
Most brands don't need more traffic. They need the traffic they already pay for to convert.
We work on what happens after the click, on the CRO and Scale Plan. Decisions are driven by the data in the CRO Brain, with PMD Cortex AI supporting the team, and a programme of tests rather than one lucky win.
The founder and the team
Paddy McLarnon, founder, and the team that does the work.
Paddy McLarnon founded PM Digital and has been a name in CRO for the last four years. He takes the first call with every brand himself, and stays close to the strategy. He has spoken at DTC Growth Summit in Miami and New York, and hosts the Funnel First podcast.
Meet the agency
Our team
The in-house team behind the work.
Your pod does the work, and the whole team backs it. Plus you, in a dedicated Slack channel with all of them.


