RechargeRecharge vs SkioShopify CRO

Skio vs Recharge: which subscription app to choose now Recharge owns Skio

Skio vs Recharge compared by a Shopify CRO agency: pricing, the features that matter for subscription brands, and what the Recharge acquisition of Skio means for you.
Paddy McLarnon
Written by
PM Digital | Founder Paddy McLarnon
Shopify CRO & performance agency for CPG and subscription brands
8 min read
Recharge Shopify App Store image showing rewards that build with each subscription order and a restart offer with a free gift in the cart

Skio vs Recharge used to be a straight fight between two rival Shopify subscription apps. Now Recharge owns Skio, so the question has changed. This guide compares the two on pricing, features and fit, explains what the acquisition means for your brand, and shares how we work with both as a Shopify CRO agency for subscription brands.

The short answer
If you are launching a subscription programme, Recharge Starter is the lower cost way in, at $149 a month with a 60-day free trial. If you are already doing real subscription volume, both platforms charge $499 a month and 1.25% + 20¢ at their main tier, so choose on features and team fit. If you are already on either one, the acquisition alone is not a reason to move.

The news

Recharge now owns Skio. What does that mean?

Recharge announced on its own blog that it has acquired Skio. Together, it says, the two platforms power more than 20,000 brands and process over $20B in GMV a year. Skio's Shopify App Store listing now carries the name "Skio, a Recharge Company".

For merchants, Recharge says nothing is changing for now. Both Recharge and Skio keep operating as they have, and your existing team stays your point of contact. Recharge says it will review elements of both platforms and share a combined roadmap over the coming months.

So the honest position is this. You are still choosing between two separate products, with separate pricing and separate support teams. You are just no longer choosing between two separate companies. Anything beyond that, such as a future merged product, has not been published, so we would not plan around it.

Why we work with both

Why PM Digital works with Skio and Recharge

Recharge and Skio both sit in the subscriptions row of the partner stack on our homepage, alongside Loop and Stay Ai. The rest of that stack covers testing, analytics and consent, led by AB Genius, the Shopify A/B testing app our team built.

We do not sell either platform and we do not push brands from one to the other. As a Shopify CRO agency, our job sits after the click: the product page, the subscription offer, the cart and the journey that turns a one-off buyer into a subscriber. That work is the same whichever app processes the recurring orders, so we build around the platform a brand already runs.

That matters for subscription brands, because the app is only half the story. The other half is how the subscribe option is presented, what the offer is worth, and whether shoppers understand why they should commit. We are a people-managed Shopify CRO agency: Paddy McLarnon, our founder, takes the first call with every brand, and the same team that plans each test also designs and builds it.

Talk with Paddy
Choosing a subscription app, or wondering if yours is holding you back?
Talk it through with Paddy, our founder. He will look at your store and your subscription offer, and tell you honestly where the quickest wins are, whichever platform you run.

Pricing

Skio vs Recharge pricing

All figures below come from the Recharge pricing page, the Skio pricing page and each app's Shopify App Store listing. Both bill in US dollars.

Recharge Skio
Entry plan Starter: $149 a month + 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction Scale: $499 a month billed annually, or $599 billed monthly
Main growth plan Scale: $499 a month + 1.25% + 20¢ per transaction Scale (its only public plan): 1.25% + 20¢ on orders involving a subscription
Top tier Custom, with volume-based rates Enterprise, custom with volume pricing
Free trial 60 days on Starter None listed
SMS Concierge SMS on Scale, billed per message segment SkioSMS (one and two way) listed in the Scale plan
Loyalty Loyalty, rewards and referrals products Subscription-first loyalty at an extra charge
App Store rating 4.8 from over 3,000 reviews 5.0 from over 240 reviews

The pattern is clear. Recharge is cheaper to start, because Starter costs less and comes with a free trial. At the main growth tier the headline price and transaction fee are the same, so the decision comes down to what each plan includes and how you like to work.

Features

The features that matter from a CRO point of view

Every subscription app lists dozens of features. These are the ones that change how many shoppers subscribe, how much each order is worth and how long subscribers stay, which is what we measure.

The subscribe option on the product page
Recharge Starter includes a subscription-first product page widget. This is where take rate is won or lost, so it is where we spend most of our testing time.
Customer portal
Both include a no-code portal where subscribers can skip, swap and reschedule. A good portal turns "I have too much" into a skip rather than a cancellation.
Cancel flows
Recharge has smart cancellation prevention on Starter. Skio has a multi-step cancel flow builder that turns cancellations into pauses, swaps and saves.
Bundles and build-a-box
Recharge adds customisable bundles and tiered discounts on Scale. Skio includes advanced build-a-box and volume discounting in its plan.
Failed payment recovery
Recharge includes failed payment recovery with smart retries on every plan. Skio includes payment recovery campaigns with timing optimisation.
Testing the journey
Recharge Scale includes subscriber journey A/B testing. Skio includes automated lifecycle journeys for welcome flows, win-backs and upsells.
Skio Shopify App Store image showing a build-a-box selector, a subscribe and save option and spend
Skio's build-a-box, subscribe and save and spend tier discounts. Image from the Skio app listing.
Recharge Shopify App Store image showing rewards that build with each subscription order and a
Recharge rewards that build with every order, plus a win-back offer. Image from the Recharge app listing.

Retention is where the two look most alike. Both give you a way to catch a subscriber before they leave and offer a better option, such as a pause, a swap or a discount.

Recharge cancellation flow asking why the subscriber wants to cancel, followed by a 10% off offer
A Recharge cancel flow: ask why, then offer the right alternative. Image from the Recharge app listing.
Skio automated journey showing a trigger when a subscriber skips a product, a seven day wait and
A Skio journey that follows up after a subscriber skips. Image from the Skio app listing.

Which to choose

Skio or Recharge: which suits your brand?

We will not tell you one is better than the other, because both are partners and both run successful subscription brands. What we can do is match each one to the situations their own sites describe.

Launching subscriptions
Recharge describes Starter as the plan for emerging brands launching a subscription programme. The lower monthly fee and 60-day trial make it the easier first step.
Scaling an established programme
At $499 a month both are built for growth. Recharge Scale adds hands-on implementation and migration support. Skio's single plan includes onboarding, migration and SMS.
Already on Recharge or Skio
Recharge says both platforms keep operating and your team stays the same. Moving now means migration work for no confirmed gain, so we would focus on the storefront instead.
Subscription boxes and memberships
Both App Store listings support subscription boxes, memberships, product bundles and replenishment, so the model you sell rarely rules either one out.

Whichever you pick, the platform will not fix a weak offer. A shopper still needs a clear reason to subscribe on the product page, and that is a design and testing problem rather than a software one. Our guides to increasing subscription take rate and subscribe and save best practices go deeper on that.

Our results

What we have built for subscription brands on Recharge

Both of the subscription case studies below ran on Shopify with Recharge, through our CRO & Scale Plan.

For Cadence, a hydration brand, we spent 12 months on research, offer testing, design and development across the UK and US stores. The site's conversion rate went from below 1% to nearly 2%, with a subscription take rate of around 70%. Those are store-wide results from the whole plan, built month after month rather than from one lucky test. A big part of it was a subscription buy box that gave shoppers free gifts across their first deliveries (Cadence case study).

Cadence subscription buy box designed by PM Digital, showing subscribe and save with three free
The subscription buy box we designed and built for Cadence, running on Recharge.

For Natrava, a beetroot supplement brand, annual Shopify sales grew 71% year on year, with Recharge subscriptions up 63%. Those are store-wide figures that include Natrava's own marketing. One winning cart test inside that programme raised subscription revenue per visitor by 9% (Natrava case study).

These are PM Digital CRO results, not Recharge or Skio results. They show where the extra subscription revenue usually comes from: the offer and the pages around the app. See more case studies, our subscription CRO service, or our guide to reducing subscription churn on Shopify.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Did Recharge buy Skio?
Yes. Recharge announced on its own blog that it has acquired Skio. Both platforms continue to operate as they did, with a combined roadmap promised in the coming months.
Is Skio cheaper than Recharge?
Not at the entry level. Recharge Starter is $149 a month plus 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction. Skio's Scale plan is $499 a month billed annually, or $599 monthly. At the main growth tier, Recharge Scale and Skio Scale are both $499 a month plus 1.25% + 20¢.
Does Skio have a free trial?
No free trial is listed on Skio's pricing page. Recharge offers a 60-day free trial on its Starter plan.
Should I switch from Skio to Recharge, or the other way?
Not because of the acquisition alone. Recharge says nothing is changing for merchants on either platform for now. Switch only if a feature, price or support gap is costing you subscribers.
Does PM Digital work with both Skio and Recharge?
Yes. Both are in the subscription partner row on our homepage. We work on the storefront around them, from the subscribe option on the product page to the cart and landing pages, and we work alongside each platform's own team on setup.
Talk with Paddy
Want more subscribers from the traffic you already pay for?
Book a call with Paddy, our founder, to talk through your store, your subscription offer and where the quickest wins are.

Sources for Recharge and Skio facts: the Recharge acquisition announcement, the Recharge pricing page, the Skio pricing page, and the Recharge and Skio Shopify App Store listings. App images are from those listings. Read the previous post in our partner series: our Dataships review.

Talk with Paddy
A chat with our founder about where the brand is.
We'll look at what you need, audit if it's needed, then talk about how we could work together. No deck, no obligation.
Book a discovery call WhatsApp us
Paddy McLarnon
Written by
Paddy McLarnon
Founder of PM Digital. Runs full-funnel CRO programmes for CPG and subscription brands on Shopify, and writes about offers, positioning and what the tests actually show.

How we work

Built for what happens after the click.

Most brands don't need more traffic. They need the traffic they already pay for to convert.

We work on what happens after the click, on the CRO and Scale Plan. Decisions are driven by the data in the CRO Brain, with PMD Cortex AI supporting the team, and a programme of tests rather than one lucky win.

The founder and the team

Paddy McLarnon, founder, and the team that does the work.

Paddy McLarnon founded PM Digital and has been a name in CRO for the last four years. He takes the first call with every brand himself, and stays close to the strategy. He has spoken at DTC Growth Summit in Miami and New York, and hosts the Funnel First podcast.

Meet the agency
Paddy McLarnon, founder of PM Digital, speaking at DTC Growth Summit Miami
Founder, speaking at DTC Growth Summit Miami

Our team

The in-house team behind the work.

Your pod does the work, and the whole team backs it. Plus you, in a dedicated Slack channel with all of them.