Black Friday Offer Maths: Will Your Discount Make Money?
A Black Friday discount only makes money if the extra orders it wins replace the margin it gives away. If an order keeps 50% of its price and you take 20% off, it now keeps 30%. You need 67% more orders just to stand still.
Most brands pick a discount by looking at competitors. The better question is what each offer leaves you per order, after costs.
This guide walks through that sum. It shows where discounts quietly lose money, and which offer types held up in our tests.
If you would rather skip the arithmetic, our free Black Friday offer calculator runs it for you.
Why a discount costs more than it looks
A discount comes off the price, but the whole cost lands on your margin. Product, shipping and fulfilment cost the same whatever the customer pays.
So 20% off is not 20% less profit. On a store that keeps half of each order, it is 40% less profit per order.
The table shows how many extra orders each discount needs to earn the same contribution as running no offer. Each column is a store that keeps that share of every order as contribution, and costs per order stay the same.
| Discount | Keeps 50% per order | Keeps 35% per order |
|---|---|---|
| 10% off | 25% more orders | 40% more orders |
| 15% off | 43% more orders | 75% more orders |
| 20% off | 67% more orders | 133% more orders |
| 25% off | 100% more orders | 250% more orders |
| 30% off | 150% more orders | 600% more orders |
| 40% off | 400% more orders | Loses money on every order |
The sum is simple. Divide your margin by your margin minus the discount, then take away one.
The rule of thumb: the thinner your margin, the faster a discount eats it. A discount bigger than your margin loses money on every order, however many you sell.

The offer sum, step by step
You need four numbers from your own Shopify and finance data. Rough figures are fine for a first pass.
A worked example
Here is the sum on a made-up store. The figures are illustrative, not a client result.
| Offer | Contribution per order | Orders needed to match no offer |
|---|---|---|
| No offer | £30 on a £60 order | 1,000 orders, £30,000 contribution |
| 20% off sitewide | £18, after £12 off | 1,667 orders, a 67% lift |
| Free gift costing £4 | £26, after the gift | 1,154 orders, a 15% lift |
Say the 20% discount brings in 1,400 orders. That feels like a great weekend.
It earns £25,200 in contribution. That is £4,800 less than running no offer at all.
The gift needs a much smaller lift to pay. It also keeps your full price intact for the rest of the year.

Offers that protect margin
The strongest offers give customers a lot of perceived value for a small real cost. Three patterns stand out in our published results.
Tiered cart thresholds
In one published cart threshold split test, a brand that relied on margin-eroding discounts tested three tiers instead. Free shipping unlocked at £70, a free gift at £80 and a second gift at £85.
The gifts had low product cost and high perceived value. The test ran for three weeks at 97% confidence.
That was not a Black Friday test. But it shows the principle: give value through the basket, not through the price.
Bundles, judged on the right number
Bundles can lift order value. They can also hurt conversion enough to lose money overall.
In our Gymproluxe case study, a two-bundle comparison lifted average order value by 14% and 29% across two variants. Both hurt conversion rate and revenue per visitor enough to stop the test after 6 days.
That is why we judge offers on revenue per visitor and profit, not order value alone.
One offer, shown everywhere
For MyoMaster, we worked across homepage messaging, Black Friday landing pages, savings displays, bundles and cart offers. We supported the storefront and promotional experience for Black Friday, and the cart redesign test lifted revenue per visitor by 45.4%.
The lesson is simple. Keep the offer clear and consistent wherever a customer lands.
Across PM Digital's case studies, the biggest order value gain came from a cart test, which lifted average order value by 33.8%. See every figure and its source on our Shopify CRO statistics page.
Run your own numbers
Our offer calculator compares up to three offers against running no offer at all. It covers sitewide discounts, spend and save, gifts, BOGO, free shipping thresholds, store credit and bundles.
Treat the output as a planning model, not a forecast. Test your lift and take rate assumptions against last year's numbers.
Before you launch
- Do you know your contribution per order, after fees, shipping and returns?
- Does your offer still make money at half the lift you expect?
- Is the offer cost the unit cost of a gift, rather than a cut to your price?
- Is the offer shown the same way on ads, landing pages, product pages and the cart?
- Will you judge the result on revenue per visitor and profit, not orders alone?
Offers also shape what happens after checkout. Our post-purchase upsell guide covers how to lift order value once the first sale is made.

The takeaway
A bigger discount is not always a better offer. Work out what each order leaves you, then check how many extra orders the offer must win.
If the answer looks unrealistic, try a threshold or a gift instead. If you want a second pair of eyes, our Shopify CRO agency team tests offers like these for Shopify brands. You can see more of what PM Digital does on our homepage, or browse our case studies.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know if my Black Friday discount will make money?
How many extra sales do I need to cover a 20% discount?
Is a free gift better than a percentage discount?
Do bundles always increase profit?
Is there a free Black Friday offer calculator for Shopify brands?
Want a view from the creative side? In Funnel First Episode 5, Kamal Razzak of MHI Media explains why the offer is the first thing worth testing.

How we work
Built for what happens after the click.
Most brands don't need more traffic. They need the traffic they already pay for to convert.
We work on what happens after the click, on the CRO and Scale Plan. Decisions are driven by the data in the CRO Brain, with PMD Cortex AI supporting the team, and a programme of tests rather than one lucky win.
The founder and the team
Paddy McLarnon, founder, and the team that does the work.
Paddy McLarnon founded PM Digital and has been a name in CRO for the last four years. He takes the first call with every brand himself, and stays close to the strategy. He has spoken at DTC Growth Summit in Miami and New York, and hosts the Funnel First podcast.
Meet the agency
Our team
The in-house team behind the work.
Your pod does the work, and the whole team backs it. Plus you, in a dedicated Slack channel with all of them.


